NFL Draft

Status
Not open for further replies.
#52      
Seems likely they’re smart enough to look at the totality of data available on his likely NFL performance, including what he accomplished in Champaign. Why would one consider only the combine?
I think just like in the workplace, metrics tend to overrule intangibles simply because they allow some basis of comparison and are traceable, even when they're incomplete or garbage metrics. Each year teams seem to lose their minds based on combine performance. And I'll take an accurate QB over a guy who can throw the ball 90yds any day of the week, and yet more times than not it's the freak athlete who gets the call.

That said, I agree with you. Whether drafted or not, some team will look at Luke and see the intangibles, the leadership, the toughness and desire, the accuracy on slants and when given a clean pocket, and his ability to be a good locker room presence and will give him that chance. And knowing Luke, he'll make good on that and turn it into a long NFL career. Just needs to get with a well managed organization that knows what they're doing.
 
#53      
I think just like in the workplace, metrics tend to overrule intangibles simply because they allow some basis of comparison and are traceable, even when they're incomplete or garbage metrics. Each year teams seem to lose their minds based on combine performance. And I'll take an accurate QB over a guy who can throw the ball 90yds any day of the week, and yet more times than not it's the freak athlete who gets the call.

That said, I agree with you. Whether drafted or not, some team will look at Luke and see the intangibles, the leadership, the toughness and desire, the accuracy on slants and when given a clean pocket, and his ability to be a good locker room presence and will give him that chance. And knowing Luke, he'll make good on that and turn it into a long NFL career. Just needs to get with a well managed organization that knows what they're doing.
All you can do is take advantage of the chance when it’s given, and I expect Altmeyer to do that. A smart, well-run team will recognize his value and give him a chance to earn his way.
 
#55      
If you want to wonder why the draft has so many busts, this article gives you an example.


Drew Allar still ranked as the #5 QB because of size and arm strength. If you don’t watch his game film and see a walking interception machine.
 
#56      
If you want to wonder why the draft has so many busts, this article gives you an example.


Drew Allar still ranked as the #5 QB because of size and arm strength. If you don’t watch his game film and see a walking interception machine.

Teams fall in love with the physical traits and think they can change a player.
 
#57      
If you want to wonder why the draft has so many busts, this article gives you an example.


Drew Allar still ranked as the #5 QB because of size and arm strength. If you don’t watch his game film and see a walking interception machine.
Luke #8 in this article. They had a lot of positives about him.
 
#60      
If you want to wonder why the draft has so many busts, this article gives you an example.


Drew Allar still ranked as the #5 QB because of size and arm strength. If you don’t watch his game film and see a walking interception machine.

Prime examples of ignoring ability to read defenses and adjust

Jamarcus Russell
Rick Mirer - already flamed out when Bears traded for him
Akili Smith
Anthony Richardson
 
#66      
Spent over 5 minutes on Gabe Jacas. This is Cowboys centric YouTube channel with a couple of Cowboys Draft Show-exes. The bald older guy was a scout for the Packers, Eagles, and Cowboys during the 90s and early 2000s.

 
#72      
Probably more or less baked in to his draft grade, it's not his speed that's impressing scouts, but that's pretty mediocre and doesn't particularly help his first round case.

You never know though, Pat Bryant had an "oh no" 40 time last year and still went at the top of his projected range.

According to the info Brett posted that 40 time is 87th percentile for edges his size so that seems better than mediocre and his start shows pretty high level explosion.
 
#73      
for edges his size
Another way of saying the same thing. Jacas isn't wowing scouts with his twitchy explosiveness, it's with his strength and physicality.

He out-benched everybody but 4 interior linemen at the combine. And for certain scouts "wrestling background" sets their heart aflutter.

I bet he's a player that's way higher on some team's boards than others.
 
#74      
Jacas will go in the 1st or 2nd rd...still looking at Gritty's last sentence...couldn't that be applied to almost any player in the draft other than the unanimous #1 pick...?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back