The mascot debate/fandom thread

#1      

Dan

Admin
Welcome to the mascot debate/fandom thread.
 
#2      
Welcome to the mascot debate/fandom thread.
Ice Hockey Mascot GIF by NHL
 
#5      
the very idea that we will have a better game day experience due to a person running around in a sesame street costume makes me laugh
 
#8      
I thought the whole game experience for the fans was much better. The music selections were better - more variety. Whoever is in charge of the music/announcements still needs to let the game breath a little bit. Part of the enjoyment of the game is to actually enjoy the ambience of a football game. Not every second between plays needs to be filled with an announcement or blaring music. The game and the crowd have a life of their own - let them breath. And pick some music that builds to a crescendo, not just tubthumps you out of your seat - although that is ok at certain times during the game.

And the encouragement for ILL...INI was better than that AI generated robotic nonsense from last year. The fake, superficial attempts to generate crowd excitement aren't always the answer.

Last night seemed more thoughtful and responsive and definitely a step in the right direction.

And of course if we could bring back the Chief, and stop catering to the woke minority, that would be another step in the right direction...but alas.
 
#9      
And of course if we could bring back the Chief, and stop catering to the woke minority, that would be another step in the right direction...but alas.

The Chief does not need to come back. And this isn't a "woke minority" (whatever that means) opinion. People seriously need to get over the Chief not being around. It's been gone long enough now that there's no need to bring it back.
 
#10      
The Chief does not need to come back. And this isn't a "woke minority" (whatever that means) opinion. People seriously need to get over the Chief not being around. It's been gone long enough now that there's no need to bring it back.
I don’t think people think Chief is ever coming back. However Chief was interwoven into our game day experience. 3 and one song selection. Since the removal the fan experience and atmosphere at both basketball and football has gone down. Not sure what caused the change.

whatever the university does it will be a mixed reaction from the fan base
 
#11      
In logo design, you want to find something you have that is unique and distinctive and build on that.

I always thought the word “Illini” had potential because it’s almost entirely vertical sticks.

ILLINI is pretty close to IIIII\II

I always thought there must be a way to take all that straight line verticality and stylize it into something that would pop visually.

The arched Illini logo emphasizes those up-down lines which is why I think it’s the best of all of them from an aesthetic viewpoint.
I also think the arched ‘ILLINI’ is the closet thing we have to a semblance of the chief’s headdress without screaming chief. I think enough time has elapsed with the anti chief period that we can play on the chief theme without causing great throwback. Remember the old logo that had the word ILLINI forming the chief’s headdress from the side profile?
 
#12      
I also think the arched ‘ILLINI’ is the closet thing we have to a semblance of the chief’s headdress without screaming chief. I think enough time has elapsed with the anti chief period that we can play on the chief theme without causing great throwback. Remember the old logo that had the word ILLINI forming the chief’s headdress from the side profile?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0272.png
    IMG_0272.png
    1.2 MB · Views: 10
#14      
I think having the letters not outlined in blue really helps. The blue outline kind of muted the helmet, when combined with an ancient 2005 Nike template, really made us look like we had a stale look during the post-Rose Bowl years. Better jerseys and a white-only Illinois really pops and is a much better look than what we had circa 2012.
What if instead of the slant Illinois we made it like the Chiefs headdress? I think it’s past time for all the anti Chief people that we can start playing around with logos that have a little bit of a Chief image without showing his face. We could even use the ILLINI here instead of just Illinois for a headdress. There’s lots of potential here even with not using the Chiefs face.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0272.png
    IMG_0272.png
    1.2 MB · Views: 6
#15      
What if instead of the slant Illinois we made it like the Chiefs headdress? I think it’s past time for all the anti Chief people that we can start playing around with logos that have a little bit of a Chief image without showing his face. We could even use the ILLINI here instead of just Illinois for a headdress. There’s lots of potential here even with not using the Chiefs face.
The NCAA is basically gone why not try it?
 
#16      
People need to seriously get over telling people to seriously get over something.
 
Back